There is one phrase that I pulled from the Wolf article that summarizes what I got out of it, “People’s lives can depend on computer simulations.” Now, before all you computer buffs start jumping down my throat, understand that I know computers and technology have helped people in the world. But my irrational self cannot help but utter a peep, “Computers are going to take over the world!” Ah to live in the days when technology stopped at horse-drawn buggies and computers weren’t even a dream of the most intellectual. But I digress.
I found Mishra’s article to be a lot more interesting and applicable to what we’ve been talking about. The discussion regarding the misconceptions a picture or image can provide for students I found particularly striking, as this is something I used to study in Utah.
Mishra says, “Pictorial imagery catches us unawares, as intellectuals, we are trained to analyze text and to treat drawings or photographs as trivial adjuncts.” Generally, I think that professionals do as he (she?) says, although students, usually looking for a break from the text, will spend a while with pictures. This is where the idea comes to play. Mishra talks about students who learn anatomy one way via the pictures in their textbook, and then are confused when it doesn’t apply to the real world (although I agree with Angie-if you thought the chest cavity was going to be organized and color coded, you’d better get the hell out of the operating room).
I liked when Mishra referred to images as “working, conceptual hallucinations.” Regardless what a picture looks like, it is not the real thing, and you will need prior knowledge to associate it with the object it is meant to portray. Perception involves, “going beyond the immediately given evidence of the senses,” and recognizing outer lying references and influences. It is important to remember that pictures are not natural; they are both themselves (the placing of ink on paper) and their representation.
Finally, I found it very interesting that depictions of dinosaurs have changed over the years. Mishra says this is because of the influence of “postmodernism,” and is merely another example of our place in a general social movement. And, I found this quote particularly striking. “At most natural moments at most places nothing much is happening.”
No comments:
Post a Comment