Tuesday, September 27, 2011

A Refreshing Read

It was refreshing to hear from the pro side of the technology v. writing battle. While much of what we’ve read in the last few weeks discussed concerns about the demise of writing in the face of technology, this week’s authors discussed the historical consistency.

Stroupe said that contradiction leads to more abstract, complex and reflective thinking. When a new technology is created, it is not meant to edge out the previous, but rather to incorporate it. Each medium arises by building recursively upon its predecessor. He says that those purists attempting to ignore new technology are holding on to a “nostalgic fiction of pure English.”

It’s a good point. “People will not stop using print anymore than they stopped talking when they became literate,” Ulmer said, “But they will use it differently.” The invention of digital communication (the computer and the internet) may not necessarily be the downfall of writing, but as Stroupe said, a salvation for English studies.

The Internet was originally designed to deliver verbal text. Baron said the computer was even touted as the gateway to literacy. It is important for those who oppose the change brought about by a new technology that writing is and has always been a technology. When writing was first being invented, Plato spoke out against it, afraid it would weaken our memories.

Ultimately, it seems to me a bit of a waste of time to oppose computers and the Internet now. While I understand these articles were written a few years back, there are still many discussions about where this new technology is taking us. The bottom line, though, is that it’s going to happen regardless. Change and evolution are unstoppable, and it may be easier to just accept it now and move on.

On that note, I’ll leave you with two quotes by Elbow that I absolutely loved.

-One of the ways people most lack control over their own lives is through lacking control over words.

-You have to let words talk to each other.

(Also, how many of you knew about Thoreau and his fortune in pencils? I had no idea).

Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Pictures AND Words

What I found to be the most interesting in the readings for this week was the significance of pictures in society. While we are conditioned to graduate from pictures, learning to explain ourselves primarily with words, we ignore the obvious: Pictures are easily understood, and by most people.


Pictures have been around long before words. Languages were depicted with symbols that could stand for entire moments in history. Words are, in fact, merely multiple symbols (or pictures) placed together to create a larger scene. Words are a means of communicating that humans developed; while there are not words in other areas of the world (no other creatures use them, or write them), all species visualize, and can understand by sight.


The reading was a great example of the integration of words and pictures. It was easy to follow and I actually enjoyed it. And although it speaks against my point, I loved the quote “Words and pictures together are considered, at best, a diversion for the masses, at worst a product of crass commercialism.” As this was written in 1992, I hope many steps have been taken to disprove that thought.


As pictures were broken down into their simplest forms and McCloud explained why we could still understand them, I was enthralled. I had never before made the connection that humans saw faces in so many obscure places because we are a self-centered people. Pictures powerfully place (like that alliteration?) ourselves in the situation, and we see ourselves reflected back in the scene. McCloud explains that often cartoons are drawn simplistically because the more universal a picture, the more people it can describe. And when we are described in a cartoon, our identity and awareness get pulled into the cartoon, and we can more easily empathize with the scene.


On an unrelated note, my mind was a bit blown when McCloud said sound could only exist in time.

Tuesday, September 13, 2011

The Age of Skimming

There was an extraordinary amount of controversy in the readings for this week. However, one thing was constant through the whole of the work we had to do. Rather than fight a world of less printed text and more visual communication, society must do what they can to embrace and understand it.

It was very interesting to read the article by Jacobs about reading. Personally, after years of struggling to convince my younger brother that reading could be just as fun if not more as watching a movie or playing a video game, it was gratifying to discover that it may just simply be that I like reading more than he does. While it may not be something I can understand completely (as I’m one of those people that used to be an avid reader, although now I would classify myself as “a person who has known the joys of reading but who can be distracted from them”).

It is fortunate that education and society are beginning to recognize that the previous way of studying literature may be outdated. While I can empathize with Sonoski on the personal dissatisfaction of skimming a book rather than reading it, I’ve learned (especially in college) that to attempt to survive without employing skimming and pecking would be suicidal to my studies. The ability to take away the most important meanings of a work without spending hours digesting each word has saved my studies on more than one occasion. While some may argue that to do so is only aiding the time when printed text is becoming obsolete, it is important to recognize that times have changed; with new means of obtaining information to study, there must also be new means of retaining that information.

I enjoyed the reading about visual communication. It was not until my junior year of college that I truly recognized the importance of visual stimulation—I took a class in visual communication and was astounded by all of the conscious and subconscious cues that exist in something as simple as a magazine advertisement. Hill makes a strong point when he says, “Communication has always been a hybrid blending of visual, written and aural forms.” We are a visual society; we learn to see before we can speak, and when we are younger the world is displayed for us in a primarily visual manner.

A few unrelated notes:

1. Blair also points out that certain enterprising scholars recognized that this information overload created a market for reference works and books that claimed to summarize important texts—We read the books so you don't have to!—or promised to teach techniques for the rapid assimilation of knowledge.

It is extremely interesting to me that from the beginning, readers who were not there simply for the joy of reading were looking for ways to obtain information faster, and with less reading on their part.

2. Liberal arts free you to make your own way through the challenges of life without requiring external props.

I never made the connection before that liberal was “liberating.”

3.Finally, a note on last week’s reading. (And this may just be the blonde setting in) but I was fascinated by the connection of trolls as more simplistic, barbaric persons in society and the lack of intelligence in many comments online. I never made the connection before that trolls were called that because of this connection. (But then again, it took me three months to figure out why the swimmers in my high school had dyed their hair red and black before a competition—our school colors were red and black).

Monday, September 5, 2011

Abstract discourse

"Rhetorical discourse comes into existence as a response to a situation, in the same sense that an answer comes into existence as a response to a question, or a solution in response to a problem."
The largest idea that I took from these readings is the importance of a writer considering as many aspects to a situation as possible. For a writer (or rhetor) to connect fully with an audience, and present his/her idea in the truest manner possible, the rhetor must answer as many questions about the topic as possible.
A successful rhetor would apply the statis theory whenever possible. Statis theory: The sequence proceeds from questions of fact and definition through questions of cause and effect and questions of value to questions of policy and procedure. A rhetor must not only look at the concrete values of their topic, such as the where/when/how/who, but also the other topics that may or may not be an influence, and just as important, the why.
"But the rhetoric of a text is also the intellectual, cognitive, affective and social considerations that guide the writer or the speaker to use the language as he or she does, and the rhetoric of the text is the effect it actually has on people who listen to it or read it."
This idea led to the next most important message that I took from this reading. Grant describes truth as a shared understanding, knowledge or belief. This position allows the rhetor and the audience to connect and bond over an idea. This also takes into consideration that the truth may mean different things to different people. People have different levels of knowledge concerning any given subject, as well as different personal attachments. "Rhetors may invite audiences to accept new identities for themselves, offering readers a vision of not who they are but of who they could be." Successful rhetors can connect with an audience, and use that connection to open a new window of thinking.
The introduction of kairos (the right or opportune time to speak or write) displayed the compassion that can/should be displayed in rhetoric discourse, as well as the timeliness of an issue. Recognizing the proper time to discuss a topic can help greatly with the success of the writing.
It was interesting to establish all the different means a successful rhetor must attack a situation from. Rhetoric writing is much more than putting words on paper or speaking them aloud; it requires an understanding of all the factors that may or may not have an effect on the topic. In order to properly address an audience, underlying issues must be addressed.
"A way of seeing is also a way of not seeing"-Kenneth Burke