It was refreshing to hear from the pro side of the technology v. writing battle. While much of what we’ve read in the last few weeks discussed concerns about the demise of writing in the face of technology, this week’s authors discussed the historical consistency.
Stroupe said that contradiction leads to more abstract, complex and reflective thinking. When a new technology is created, it is not meant to edge out the previous, but rather to incorporate it. Each medium arises by building recursively upon its predecessor. He says that those purists attempting to ignore new technology are holding on to a “nostalgic fiction of pure English.”
It’s a good point. “People will not stop using print anymore than they stopped talking when they became literate,” Ulmer said, “But they will use it differently.” The invention of digital communication (the computer and the internet) may not necessarily be the downfall of writing, but as Stroupe said, a salvation for English studies.
The Internet was originally designed to deliver verbal text. Baron said the computer was even touted as the gateway to literacy. It is important for those who oppose the change brought about by a new technology that writing is and has always been a technology. When writing was first being invented, Plato spoke out against it, afraid it would weaken our memories.
Ultimately, it seems to me a bit of a waste of time to oppose computers and the Internet now. While I understand these articles were written a few years back, there are still many discussions about where this new technology is taking us. The bottom line, though, is that it’s going to happen regardless. Change and evolution are unstoppable, and it may be easier to just accept it now and move on.
On that note, I’ll leave you with two quotes by Elbow that I absolutely loved.
-One of the ways people most lack control over their own lives is through lacking control over words.
-You have to let words talk to each other.
(Also, how many of you knew about Thoreau and his fortune in pencils? I had no idea).
I had no idea about Thoreau's pencil thing, either. It must be a well kept secret.
ReplyDeleteI wonder what comes after the internet?
Whoa. After the internet. Mind just blown.
ReplyDelete