There was an extraordinary amount of controversy in the readings for this week. However, one thing was constant through the whole of the work we had to do. Rather than fight a world of less printed text and more visual communication, society must do what they can to embrace and understand it.
It was very interesting to read the article by Jacobs about reading. Personally, after years of struggling to convince my younger brother that reading could be just as fun if not more as watching a movie or playing a video game, it was gratifying to discover that it may just simply be that I like reading more than he does. While it may not be something I can understand completely (as I’m one of those people that used to be an avid reader, although now I would classify myself as “a person who has known the joys of reading but who can be distracted from them”).
It is fortunate that education and society are beginning to recognize that the previous way of studying literature may be outdated. While I can empathize with Sonoski on the personal dissatisfaction of skimming a book rather than reading it, I’ve learned (especially in college) that to attempt to survive without employing skimming and pecking would be suicidal to my studies. The ability to take away the most important meanings of a work without spending hours digesting each word has saved my studies on more than one occasion. While some may argue that to do so is only aiding the time when printed text is becoming obsolete, it is important to recognize that times have changed; with new means of obtaining information to study, there must also be new means of retaining that information.
I enjoyed the reading about visual communication. It was not until my junior year of college that I truly recognized the importance of visual stimulation—I took a class in visual communication and was astounded by all of the conscious and subconscious cues that exist in something as simple as a magazine advertisement. Hill makes a strong point when he says, “Communication has always been a hybrid blending of visual, written and aural forms.” We are a visual society; we learn to see before we can speak, and when we are younger the world is displayed for us in a primarily visual manner.
A few unrelated notes:
1. Blair also points out that certain enterprising scholars recognized that this information overload created a market for reference works and books that claimed to summarize important texts—We read the books so you don't have to!—or promised to teach techniques for the rapid assimilation of knowledge.
It is extremely interesting to me that from the beginning, readers who were not there simply for the joy of reading were looking for ways to obtain information faster, and with less reading on their part.
2. Liberal arts free you to make your own way through the challenges of life without requiring external props.
I never made the connection before that liberal was “liberating.”
3.Finally, a note on last week’s reading. (And this may just be the blonde setting in) but I was fascinated by the connection of trolls as more simplistic, barbaric persons in society and the lack of intelligence in many comments online. I never made the connection before that trolls were called that because of this connection. (But then again, it took me three months to figure out why the swimmers in my high school had dyed their hair red and black before a competition—our school colors were red and black).
I was definitely on the other end of the spectrum: My sister loved reading and I didn't so I would sit on her bed and watch her read, waiting for her to finish so we could go do something else. (She is my little sister) I did try to read... a lot... and as a result, I have a large unread library in my home... I love to buy books but can't get past the first chapter or two of most... unless they are some form of non-fiction (and then I don't feel so bad about not "finishing" it since I'll always have it on hand.
ReplyDeleteAnd as far as trolling is concerned: I was in the same boat when I first heard the term from a techy friend :)
Also, I like your page... it looks good :)
1) I didn't make the trolling connection until I read your blog just now. Did I miss something?
ReplyDelete2) I laughed out loud at "now I would classify myself as 'a person who has known the joys of reading but who can be distracted from them.'" I'm with you on that one.
3) I wonder if things like CliffsNotes could be considered just as effective as the texts they summarize, because if the person needs CliffsNotes in the first place, they either can't understand the original or don't have the time to read it and wouldn't be able to pick out the important points from a skim, so is somebody else reading the book so you don't have to really a bad thing in the end, or does it promote the spread of more knowledge to more people? That was a big run on sentence.
Like Karen, I was thinking about CliffNotes here. And when I first heard that CliffNotes existed, I was blown away. It seemed like cheating. But then again, so did skimming at that point.
ReplyDeleteHonestly, I'm not sure what I think, but I'm starting here: it's a fact--people use CliffNotes and people skim. Why? The easy answer would be laziness, but that's too neat 'n tidy to be the only truth. Besides, I don't think I'm lazy and I used CliffNotes once during a lit class. Here's why: It makes me crazy to speed read through texts that I'm also supposed to be drawing deep meaning from, and semester reading loads are heavy enough to require that (for me and my schedule). I have zero background in literature (even the classics--as a child, I did not have the opportunity to read them--sad), and I wanted to be able to be part of the interaction of classroom discussion and not make a complete fool of myself. So I checked what I thought about "The Iliad" with what CliffNotes said, and that made me feel brave enough to talk about it in class. My other options would have been 1) not participate in the conversations, or 2)become overwhelmed, think I was stupid and drop the course. Reading CliffNotes also helped me find a chapter that sounded interesting to focus on for my close reading (because every chapter was just about war and arrogant dudes when I read it alone). It was partially a time thing, and in this way, I was able to devote more time to reading deeply and writing meaningfully on a portion of the text rather than not understand any of it. (And I say this confident that I am somewhere around normal when it comes to reading comprehension--it's a strong point for me, but even so, I found a use for CliffNotes that, I think, furthered my education more than reading on my own would have.)
By the way, I have no idea what the general option of CliffNotes is, especially among English majors: is everyone going to point and laugh at me now? I care not--I learned more that way, and isn't learning the point here? I haven't returned to them, because most texts are fun to wrestle meaning out of! =)
I too can relate to the “a person who has known the joys of reading but who can be distracted from them”. Pleasure reading has definitely dropped off quite a bit for me since I started my college education. If this is a result of an increased reading load or loads of other social distractions, I'm not sure.
ReplyDeleteI liked your view on skimming. I think a lot of us can recognize how integral skimming is for absorbing large chunks of information in a small amount of time. Because of the incredible volume of material at our fingertips, I do not see a problem with skimming or pecking. When it comes down to it, aren't we still being exposed to more accurate and detailed information than ever before? Even if we're not reading a text in it's entirety, I believe that after thorough skimming and pecking, we will have developed a MUCH more complete view of whatever we're researching.
Cliffnotes is an awesome tool. But, I think it definitely can be used to "cheat", in a grade school environment. If skimming a dense text leaves you with an incomplete understanding, by all means fill the gap with Cliffnotes.