"Rhetorical discourse comes into existence as a response to a situation, in the same sense that an answer comes into existence as a response to a question, or a solution in response to a problem."
The largest idea that I took from these readings is the importance of a writer considering as many aspects to a situation as possible. For a writer (or rhetor) to connect fully with an audience, and present his/her idea in the truest manner possible, the rhetor must answer as many questions about the topic as possible.
A successful rhetor would apply the statis theory whenever possible. Statis theory: The sequence proceeds from questions of fact and definition through questions of cause and effect and questions of value to questions of policy and procedure. A rhetor must not only look at the concrete values of their topic, such as the where/when/how/who, but also the other topics that may or may not be an influence, and just as important, the why.
"But the rhetoric of a text is also the intellectual, cognitive, affective and social considerations that guide the writer or the speaker to use the language as he or she does, and the rhetoric of the text is the effect it actually has on people who listen to it or read it."
This idea led to the next most important message that I took from this reading. Grant describes truth as a shared understanding, knowledge or belief. This position allows the rhetor and the audience to connect and bond over an idea. This also takes into consideration that the truth may mean different things to different people. People have different levels of knowledge concerning any given subject, as well as different personal attachments. "Rhetors may invite audiences to accept new identities for themselves, offering readers a vision of not who they are but of who they could be." Successful rhetors can connect with an audience, and use that connection to open a new window of thinking.
The introduction of kairos (the right or opportune time to speak or write) displayed the compassion that can/should be displayed in rhetoric discourse, as well as the timeliness of an issue. Recognizing the proper time to discuss a topic can help greatly with the success of the writing.
It was interesting to establish all the different means a successful rhetor must attack a situation from. Rhetoric writing is much more than putting words on paper or speaking them aloud; it requires an understanding of all the factors that may or may not have an effect on the topic. In order to properly address an audience, underlying issues must be addressed.
"A way of seeing is also a way of not seeing"-Kenneth Burke
If truth is a shared understanding or belief, is truth then the product of just a collective opinion? You said truth may mean different things to different people, and I think that is something really interesting. Not to just blah blah blah add on and not say anything worth saying.....but its a powerful notion that we, human beings, can be so different. And an equally powerful notion is that a powerful orator can manipulate the people based on a common collective belief if his ability allows it. It makes you think of how much rhetoric has influenced history through subtle manipulation and propaganda
ReplyDelete