Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Everything is Plagiarized

Porter and Johnson-Eilola seem to agree, that texts are not to be thought of as whole entities, but rather as works built off the fragments and pieces of previous texts. Porter says, “Not infrequently, books speak of books.” Text is constantly being modified and altered; each new text has the potential to alter the Text in some way. Often, texts not only refer to other texts, but actually contain them (both seen in reference and in weblinks online).

This raises the question of creativity. How much of an idea is original? (Eilola said the more factual a text, the less creative it is. However, I don’t agree with this idea. I think rather, the trick is to be more creative when discussing the facts). This is a thought I had a few years back; is anything I write or type actually new and unique to me, or has it all been written somewhere else? Does the fact that someone else may have had this idea in another time or place, regardless whether I had knowledge of it, mean they have more of a right to the idea than I do?

Porter suggests that a writer is now a collector of fragments. He quotes Halliday, “Creativeness does not consist in producing new sentences. The newness of a sentence is a quite unimportant-and unascertainable- property and ‘creativity’ in language lies in the speaker’s ability to create new meaning; to realize the potentiality of language for the indefinite extension of its resources to new contexts of situation.” We have reached a new stage in writing; everything new has been created, and it now up to us as writers to rearrange and alter previous information in a way to address our specific community. The repeatability of certain textual fragments is called iterability.

Eilola suggests that we have reached a postmodern world, where smaller bits of texts are easier for society to handle, and therefore preferred (I didn’t grasp what postmodern meant until I read this article). Porter even says that modern text IS intertext; that every text incorporates other information.

There were a few other ideas I found interesting. Eilola says that intertexts have become a simplified reality. These texts can show a brief moment in time, isolated in a way that it may be viewed differently than actuality.

I also liked Porter’s definition of rules. Rules prescribe what is true and false, what is reasonable and foolish, and what is meant and what not.

Finally, I found it incredibly interesting that Jefferson’s few attempts at original expression were the least acceptable to congress when writing the Declaration.

The whole world is plagiarized.

1 comment:

  1. I agree it does seem to be increasingly difficult to find authentic texts. However, I think texts based off of previous texts can be just as influential and creative now that they are more accessible online.

    ReplyDelete